Thanks for all the input, guys. I put away my latest failure; might try to come back and rescue it later. I have one good stave left, a 43" long by 4" wide juniper stave that might make a good paddle bow. Sounds like I need to get a round rasp, move toward the handle instead of away from it, and as usual, slow down and be more patient. Osage and Eric, that's some gorgeous work.
Pat, please tell me more about faceting. I remember reading about that somewhere but it all kind of gets jumbled up in my brain.