Riley, a lot of different stuff will work. The reason for a lot of people using certain glues is because they are compatible with the gasket laquer finish often used on commercial shafts. I've had good results with superglue, contact cement, homemade hide glue, household cement like Duco, fletch tape, just about any kind of good glue will work unless it's incompatible with the finish on your arrows. I like superglue because it sets up fast and holds tight and seems to stick to most finishes.