Eric, Love the turtle shell call, you are correct, the legality of owning them is determined by state.
As a callmaker I would never kill a turtle just for the shell but if the turtle has already passed on to the great pond in the sky, his shell makes an awesome turkey call.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/cc135/cc1357fac4d828fb021bdac92197a669c466adfa" alt="Gobbler :G"
Good luck hunting!
Kevin