I’m sure there is a way to screw it up, but I have sinewed a bow with glue that did not even gel for several day. I don’t know what I did, I think I heated it too long and it just dried and not gelled, and the bow worked out just fine, the sinew job just didn’t look very good. I did get rid of the glue after that and started a new batch.
As far as it being sticky, it never really is that sticky, mostly slimy, and a bit tacky