I never had LLbean boots but I've broken in plenty of work boots. I always like to start out only wearing them a couple hours a day until they get more broke in. Jeb I know they sell some spray can stuff for breaking in baseball gloves, might help I really don't know. It seems like the harder they break in the longer they last. Yes Ryan I agree, the more broke in the more comfortable until the soles give up or the leather cracks or wears out.
Bjrogg