Really this brings a thought to mind.If a person ever makes hide glue for themselves they will see the dramatic shrinkage that it does spread out in a thin layer to be broken up into granuals for reconstituded use.
If the sinew can absorb the hide glue properly in the right state before being applied to the bow I believe loin or leg sinew is equally as good as each other.
I know there are videos of koreans using loin sinew combing and combing the hide glue into the fibers over and over.This not only keeps the fibers straight which is obvious but also induces the hide glue into the fibers of the sinew.
Hide glue IMHO opinion has super enhancing qualities with sinew making the sinew even more resilient.
Ed, I just measured the three grades of glue I used to duplicate he TP test mentioned in the other thread.
weight water:glue ratio shrinkage
379 3:1 10%
251 2.25:1 8.5%
251 5:1 8.5% this mix was twice the recommended water
135 1.25:1 8%
I should note that the three different weights of hide glue, when mixed with the recommended amount of water, had pretty much the same viscosity.
This compares with 17% shrinkage that was reported with knox in the other thread.
I do not know how fair this test is, as the tissue is free to shrink. When glue is bonded to wood, one side is restrained.
I also dried some deer backstrap sinew. the sinew was restrained somewhat, as I suspected that just drying a strand of sinew unrestrained would allow it to shrivel more than it might if it was in matrix with glue. Three different pieces showed very little shrinkage. The pieces were placed between two slats of cedar held together with a few wraps of electrical tape. They were stuck to the wood when the slats were separated, and when free from both pieces, measured 1% shorter than the razor cuts made when the sinew was trimmed wet before the slats were sandwiched. Not a calibrated test by any means, but my impression is that it did not take all that much to prevent shrinkage, so the idea of it being "tensioned" inside a cured matrix seems dubious, and if it is in a matrix with glue that shrinks more, then what does that say about our understanding of the mechanics?
Link to glue specs and info
http://www.primitivearcher.com/smf/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=63182.0;attach=139366