yes it would perform well,, the narrow limb would have less mass,, if it did not follow the string much ,, it would have nice cast,, you need to make some and see for yourself,,, the little wider tip,, would not effect it that much,, especially in a white wood,, the wider tip was probaly better suited for a sinew or rawhide sting anyway,,,, if you shot a bow every day for a living,, if you wanted more cast,, going up in weight was probably not an issue,,at all,, if the bow was for hunting, and you were close to your game, the cast was probably not an issue anyway,, ,,, course I am just guessing,, the reason there are so many of them,, is it was an effective bow, that was fairly easy to make,, and didnt take that much wood,,