Wow, you guys are awesome! I totally appreciate the inspiration and willingness to help me out.
Little Ben, you're right - the clothespin says my draw is 27.5", not 28" like I thought. Maybe I'm bending my elbow more than last time I measured. Loope, you're on to something. I had thought about my arrows. The ones I'm using now are poplar and probably on the heavy side. I haven't weighted them; I don't have a grain scale.
I measured the cross section of the bow - its a 1 3/8" x 13/16". The crosssection is rectangular, with the belly dead flat and the back slightly rounded. So not a classic "D" section ELB. But the bowyer said it needed a flat belly since hazel is weak in compression. In the picture, I'm holding it the way it was sent to me, with the handle just below center so the arrow pass is right at the center. Based on what you guys are telling me that the weaker limb should be on top, I'm tempted to flip it over and try to shoot it that way just to see what the difference would be. But its still too long, right? And it still has a funky kink in the limb (which, BTW, has about an inch or so of set with the bow unstrung - hadn't really noticed before)
Okay, what do I need to fix this thing? Where do I start?