Could have been a reject, but you never know. When thrown on a dart backed by an atlatl, I suppose all you really need is a sharp tip and accuracy. It certainly is ugly, but I tell you what...At work I'm sorting some 5,000 points into basic types and many of them are quite badly made, especially from the Woodland period. Archaic not so much and certainly not paleo when it comes to bad workmanship. Mississippian tools & weapons are generally all well made too.