I'm a complete convert. Nowadays I can't even look at my old 60+inch flatbows, let alone bother to carry them around in the woods and use them. For the past year I've been shooting 46-50" D-bows, 19-22" draws. Presently I'm as accurate with these on a good day as I ever was with the longer bows, but consistency is not quite the same yet (it's easier to fumble with a short one). I can tell you, after sneaking in the bush with a 48-incher the man-tall bows suddenly feel extremely cumbersome and limiting. And a whole new mother load of bow wood unfolds once all the flawless four-foot saplings (formerly "just too short") are fair game.
The thing is, most guys trying out a short bow never give it a real chance. Remember how you felt when you first started shooting any bow? How "accurate" you were? How awkward? Shooting a couple dozen or even hundred short-draw shots while still in the long-draw mode tells little of the short bow's potential. Shooting a short bow exclusively for months, day in, day out, with a will to get accurate with this very bow, tells more. Quick pie-plate groups inside 25 yards is accurate enough for my needs. Even with these short draws, a stable, razor-sharp broadhead arrow of adequate mass is deadly enough, too.
Tuukka