Kegan, someone gave me a red oak wide handled bow a while back, the tiller looks perfect and it looks like it could be shot with either limb as the top. If I hold the bow one way it will shoot stiff spined arrows 2 feet to the left (55spine from 45# bow) If I flip the bow over it will shoot the same arrows perfectly center, I am assuming there is some torquing in the bow I cant see or feel. Spine is important, it sounds to me like those arrows are spined right for your bow the way it is built, have you tried this method with several different bows, or tried flipping this bow over and shooting it? Steve