I'm not a terribly experienced fletcher.
My first arrows had pigeon feather fletching, since it was all I had at the time and I just wanted to shoot. They were absolutely rubbish. I did combine them with some I found from a sparrowhawk once but they were just as bad.
I havent tried crow, but I have a few crow feathers lying around, could make some cool arrows, sort of evil looking.
My current set are fletched with Canada Goose feathers that I found. They were primary wing feathers and were enourmous, and very rigid. I found them very good, but since I don't hunt (illegal in the UK+canada goose doesn't taste that good) I have to work with droppers.
Does anyone know if its possible to get hold of domestic goose feathers from a butchers? Could be interesting.