I'm working on a set of arrows for AITH; I finished them with Watco Danish Oil, wiped on X3, then 3 coats of Watco wipe on polyurethane; they look great so far. 3 more coats of poly after crown dip and cresting, they're drying now. I plan on doing the Danish oil soak next time, but I've been wondering how pine tar would do as an arrow finish. I'm thinking it might remain too tacky, but it seems pine pitch varnish would remain tacky too (haven't tried either one yet).