I really appreciate the input you all have given on this. As a side note, I scored a nice (I hope) 'vintage' drawknife on e-bay this weekend. 6 inch straight and the seller stated it had never been resharpened. Still the factory bevel. Looking forward to getting it and trying it out.
As another note, it seems to me that it depends allot on the wood being used. Having worked with hickory and elm, I can see the need for sharp tools, I was just curious about the dull option because of the mention in TBB.