Thanks guys, I'll go try it again. The bow is (to the best of my scale's ability) about 54#. The second and third shots flashed "DUPL", which I figured was the chrono's way of telling me that it did indeed get a new number, but it just happened to be the same as the last number.
Steve, is it possible the bow just has a maximum response speed? There has to be an end to gains at some point, or a 1gr arrow would be approaching the speed of light... The bow design isn't ideal, either, it's another skinny serviceberry, only an inch wide at the handle, 68" N2N, and about 19oz. There's a deflex kink near the handle I had to heat twice to prevent hinging, even though the bow was left almost untillered at that point for the same reason. An ideal bow design should have arrows leaving at 180fps at my 30" draw I would think.