What do I know, I just build shooting sticks.
I've always contemplated the term Bowyer.
Many layout their designs on paper then transfer them onto wood. They make specific cuts, they look at thickness and limb length and truly make a beautiful bow. Allan made me a static recurve that is just awsome. It has matching limb widths and thickness. The handle is cut out and a shelf is cut in and it is sanded and is a basic work or art.
Then you have guys like me. I get a stave, take it down with no specific idea in mind. I don't steam out limb twists but use them when they don't break....LOL. I truly have no idea what the bow will look like when I start. My horsebows start as unbacked longbows that I complete without a finish, shoot in, then cut down, recurve, and sinew then retiller as needed.
We all fall into our own diff styles that we like to build. I truly make crappy board bows, but give me a stave and it's a diff. story. Not that I can not make a board bow, been there done that, but they do not perform and I don't enjoy them like a stave bow.
As far as when you are considered a bowyer, well I guess that depends on the guy making the bow. When the person building can sit down and talk bow building, not be an expert but knows enough that he, the builder is content with his ideas. Now, there will be conflicting ideas as many who have been doing this for awhile know. Many big time bowyers debate limb styles, thickness, recurve %, etc...
I've broken two of the last 4 bowys I've made. I guess the old saying is true, if you are not breaking them, you're not making them. I'm working
on a glued up lemonwood, purpleheart, and bamboo bow now that I traded for. It is a blank, so I feel that I am cheating, but it is such a beautiful blank that I had to trade for it. It will be turned into a 72" Cherokee D bow, with a little ELB flare. Then it will be back to a piece of hickory that is calling.........Frankkkkkk........make me something.