When I first started making arrows, I wanted to get a cresting machine and do some cresting. Well, it never happened because I figured the price of a cresting machine would buy more arrowmaking supplies. I'd do cresting by hand and was always trying to do the fancy-pants cresting and it was decidely bad. So, I'd just do a couple lines with a black Sharpie marker to mark my arrows. (But in this area, I'm probably the only guy who shoots wood shafts so I don't really NEED to mark them, ok, ok, but still...)
So, I looked through some Steve Allely prints in Native American Bows Quivers and Arrows (man, we have this book at our library and I can use it for free!) and it struck me. Hey! My ancestors didn't have cresting machines!!!! I'm going about this all wrong! Don't make up a 1950s style field archery club crest. Use something a lot older! So, I got an idea and used red iron oxide based paint for my red and black iron oxide based paint for my black. Just did some simple crest by hand that I'll use for my own self. And they came out pretty good...but primitive. I marked the shafts with a stencil to where I wanted the marks. And they're uniform to about 1/8 of an inch, LOL! And not all straight. But, dang, they look like arrows from the ancient past! The paint isn't glossy; they're Earth-tones, after all. I'm happy. Wish I had a digital camera to post pics.
So, now I've been able to let go of that weird craving for a cresting machine at last. I use a little handsaw to cut my shafts to length and a hand taper tool to taper them. Not a single electric appliance was used. Sometimes simpler really is better.