Art. trust me, it has nothing to do with your finish.....lol. I know that yours works. What I was more interested in, and you explaned it pretty good is how you apply it. I have tried it,,,my way,,,and I have glued everything but my hands to the shafts. I tried using a piece of feather to spread it out.....only got the feather stuck...lol. I was reading somewhere, that someone spread it on, the sanded it, then applied it again and so on until they got what they wanted as a finish. I will give your way ART a try and see if I can get the dang stuff to run down the shaft.