When I use a wipe on poly, I'm rubbing it dry with a clean t shirt a few seconds after applying it, and getting a nice shine. Mineral Oil is often applied first, or used by itself, and will waterproof your bow if you get it burnished. Plus it looks great, and you can drink it if you are constipated...
I have used most of what is posted here, and they all work fine. I think humidity affects some of these finishes and why I prefer the ones I can wipe off and get dry quickly.